Cross Town News
Cross Town News India Follow Editor Rahil Gupta on   Twitter   Instagram

High Court refuses to quash corruption charges against Jammu Dev Authority Officer/Officials


High Court refuses to quash corruption charges against Jammu Dev Authority Officer/Officials

JAMMU, Nov 20: Justice Sanjay Dhar has refused to quash corruption and criminal conspiracy charges against former Jammu Development Authority Executive Engineer and others in connection with the alleged irregular allotment of Rs 40.83-lakh renovation contract without inviting tenders, observing that the manner in which the contract was awarded disclosed a prima facie case of favoritism, nepotism and abuse of official position.

Court dismissed the petition filed by Xen and others challenging the chargesheet arising out of FIR No. 10/2020 registered by the Anti-Corruption Bureau, Jammu, as well as the order of the Special Judge Anti-Corruption, Jammu, framing charges under Section 5(1)(d) read with Section 5(2) of the Jammu and Kashmir Prevention of Corruption Act and Section 120-B of the Ranbir Penal Code.

 According to the prosecution, the then Vice Chairman of JDA had initially approved the installation of ten two-ton air conditioners and allied electrical works through a competitive tendering process.

Following the invitation of tenders, M/s Lumen Engineers emerged as the lowest bidder (L1).

 However, instead of awarding the contract to the lowest bidder, the tender process was cancelled on April 8, 2011, allegedly on the verbal directions of the then Vice Chairman.

Subsequently, the scope of work was expanded to include renovation and interior works, and the contract was awarded to a private firm on a nomination basis without inviting fresh tenders.

The prosecution alleged that the decision was taken in conspiracy with the then Superintending Engineer, who has since died, and other officials to confer an undue benefit upon the selected contractor.

The total value of the contract was Rs 40.83 lakh, against which Rs 40.53 lakh was released to the contractor.  The ACB also alleged that the firm's licence had expired before the work was executed.

During the investigation, the Engineering Wing of the ACB examined the executed works and initially assessed a loss of Rs 1,56,428 to the Government exchequer.

After deducting Rs 9,600 towards transportation and installation charges, the alleged net loss was quantified at Rs 1,46,828.

After examining the rival submissions and the material on record, Justice Dhar rejected the contention that the renovation and air-conditioning works were so highly specialized that competitive bidding could be dispensed with.

The court held that awarding the contract without inviting tenders amounted to a clear case of favoritism and nepotism and that the officials concerned had prima facie abused their official positions.

The court reiterated that interference with criminal charges at the preliminary stage is permissible only within limited legal parameters and that disputed questions relating to evidence must ordinarily be decided by the trial court.

Holding that the material collected by the investigating agency disclosed sufficient grounds for proceeding against the accused, Justice Dhar found no merit in the petition and dismissed it.


 

 


   Popular News

Top